An extraordinary journey through India, where magic, deception and reality become rather difficult to tell apart.
It has been quite a few years since I read The Sorcerer’s Apprentice by Tahir Shah. To be perfectly honest, I no longer remember every episode, every character or every strange encounter along the way.
But I remember one thing very clearly.
I could hardly put the book down.
And considering how many books eventually end up gathering dust on a shelf, I think that says quite a lot.
An India Beyond the Travel Brochures
Tahir Shah takes his readers on a journey through a side of India that has very little to do with luxury hotels, famous monuments or the usual tourist attractions.
Instead, he enters the extraordinary world of Indian magicians, holy men, mystics and professional tricksters.
His fascination with magic began during his childhood in England, when he encountered an Indian magician. Years later, he sets off for India to explore that mysterious world for himself.
Eventually, he becomes an apprentice to Hakim Feroze, a formidable master of illusion in Calcutta.
And this is certainly no comfortable apprenticeship.
What follows is a remarkable journey through a country where the boundaries between belief, performance, trickery and genuine mystery are not always easy to recognise.
The Strange Art of Keeping a Reader Hooked
I have always enjoyed travel books that take me somewhere unexpected. Not simply from one destination to another, but into situations I would probably never experience myself.
This book did exactly that.
There is something irresistible about following a traveller who deliberately ventures into a world most of us know almost nothing about.
You find yourself wondering what will happen next, whom he will encounter and whether the next extraordinary demonstration will turn out to be a clever trick or something that cannot be explained quite so easily.
And that is where Tahir Shah succeeds so well.
He doesn’t simply describe places. He takes the reader along on an adventure.
I remember being completely absorbed in it.
Not because I believed everything I was reading, but because I wanted to know what came next.
Magic, Tricks and a Good Deal of Human Nature
What makes the subject particularly fascinating is that magic is not always about making things disappear or pulling rabbits out of hats.
It is also about people.
About those who perform extraordinary feats, those who desperately want to believe in them, and those who know perfectly well how to turn that belief into a profitable business.
India provides a remarkable setting for such a story, with its long traditions of spirituality, storytelling and street performance.
Shah explores that world with curiosity and a willingness to put himself into some decidedly uncomfortable situations.
And somewhere along the way, the book becomes more than an account of learning magic tricks.
It is also an exploration of human gullibility, imagination and the rather complicated relationship between what we see and what we choose to believe.
A Book That Stayed with Me
I won’t pretend to remember every detail after all these years.
Perhaps I should read it again.
But I do remember the enjoyment, the curiosity and that familiar little argument with myself late at night.
Just one more chapter.
Which, as anyone who loves reading knows, can be a dangerous promise.
There are books whose plots you remember almost perfectly but which leave very little impression.
And then there are books whose details gradually fade, while the pleasure of reading them remains.
For me, The Sorcerer’s Apprentice belongs firmly in the second category.
If you enjoy unusual travel stories, eccentric characters and journeys far removed from conventional tourism, I can certainly recommend it.
It might even make you look at the next street magician a little differently.
The Book
Title: The Sorcerer’s Apprentice
Author: Tahir Shah
First published: 1998
Genre: Travel writing / Adventure / Non-fiction
German title: Der Zauberlehrling von Kalkutta – Reise durch das magische Indien
Read in German, remembered with great affection, and perhaps due for another journey through its pages.
Discover more from Lizz & I
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

